Burger wars: Where does 5 Guys rank?

Lets see what you all chose for me

Doug F posted in Burgers
41w ago
4.7K

I asked you all to chose a burger from 5 Guys for review and overwhelmingly you chose the bacon cheeseburger. I know it's not like there was a lot of choice.

Does it taste as good as it looks? The short answer is... way better.

As I always do I tried a bite of the meat on it's own. The beef was good it did not taste like it was frozen and that's a good thing. I do think that 5 Guys has some great buns, they are so soft but they don't disintegrate as you eat. In fact they are so good that my wife had some leftover top and bottom bun after she was done eating and I ate that as well. The cheese is your standard American cheese slices and there was two of them. The lettuce was trying to hold up but was losing its crispness. The diced onions were nice and still had some crispness with a nice onion flavor. As for the pickles they were very middle of the road and that's the best I can say about those. The jalapenos were very nice, they are fresh and not the pickled type other places use, these tasted fresh and had a nice crispness to them and they actually had a little heat to them as well. Now lets talk bacon, this bacon was done right. It had crunch to it as well as a little chewiness and there was enough of it to taste it, plus it actually tasted like bacon.

I do admit that when you unwrap it from the foil it does look like a bit of a mess honestly but once you start eating it you will forget all about how it looked. These are hefty burgers that have some size to them and that is why they cost more. I guess you get what you pay for and I would gladly pay for another one right now. So with that being said I have to rank 5 Guys in second place right below my hometown Carl's townhouse.

Thanks to John Battersby for the power board

Thanks to John Battersby for the power board

So do you all agree or disagree with me? Tell me in the comments below. Stay wonderful Foodtribe. I love you all!

Join In

Comments (38)

  • I'm just here to appeal the unfairly low placement of the BigMac at No. 4

      9 months ago
    • I think where it is ranked is more than fair considering I figured it would be way lower.

        9 months ago
    • Should be #1

        9 months ago
  • 🤤 i would kill for 5 guys right now! did you try their cajun fries too? those are honestly my favorite fries...in the world

      9 months ago
    • I must agree, it's hard to beat a bag of their cajun fries.

        9 months ago
  • All I ever had at a 5 Guys was one Cheese Burger All the Way. Just without them nasty Tomatoes. And that was in April 2015.

      9 months ago
    • Good man for skipping the tomatoes. That has been a while ago then.

        9 months ago
    • Oh yes. I was at Times Square/ 42nd Street Station and did not want McDonalds. Then I saw a Five Guys.

        9 months ago
  • It's been awhile since I had one

      9 months ago
  • Damn I need a burger right now

      9 months ago
    • Trust me I do as well. The top picture looks like a hot mess but the picture after a few bites looks so good it makes me want another one. 😀

        9 months ago
38