- This actually looks good but is packed full of fail!

FAILED! I Tried to Make a Classic and It Was Horrible!

Creamed Chipped Beef, a.k.a.: S*** On a Shingle

27w ago

5.3K

For some reason I got the craving for Creamed Chipped Beef, a United States military classic that is more commonly know as "S*** On a Shingle" to many military veterans. I first became acquainted with it in the diners of New Jersey and through my grandfather, a retired Air Force fighter pilot, who whipped this up for me in my way-back youth. From what I understand, this dish's history reaches all the way back before World War I, appearing in the Manual of Army Cooks from 1910 and it has been prepared through many conflicts and wars as it was easy to prepare in mass quantities. The ingredients at the time traveled well; cured meat and condensed milk didn't spoil easily and could be easily transported long distances. Most importantly, it fed a lot of hungry soldiers and provided much needed nutrition for a fighting force.

S*** On a Shingle is really easy to make! You start by making a roux of butter and flour, and then stir in milk. Seasoning can be added; the most common seems to be nutmeg and a little pepper. I did something a little different by adding pepper, a couple dashes of Worcestershire, and a few dashes of Tabasco sauce. Once your S*** On a Shingle gravy is cooked to the desired consistency, sliced strips of dried beef are stirred in. This concoction is served over toast and is a hearty meal with its filling, thick gravy and salty beef.

Pretty simple gravy. How can this be messed up?

Pretty simple gravy. How can this be messed up?

Dried beef!

Dried beef!

Mmmmmmm. Cured meat product.

Mmmmmmm. Cured meat product.

The dried beef is sliced into strips and stirred into the white gravy.

The dried beef is sliced into strips and stirred into the white gravy.

So how did I fail at making this easy dish? Holy crap, my S*** On a Shingle was soooooooooo salty!!! It was so salty that I couldn't finish my plate of it, and I like salty foods! I found out later that I needed to quickly soak my dried beef in water to relieve it of some if its sodium. Just ten seconds in some water would have made my plate of S*** On a Shingle much more palatable. Lesson learned!

To me, this actually looks good! I understand if S*** On a Shingle's appearance may be off-putting to some.

To me, this actually looks good! I understand if S*** On a Shingle's appearance may be off-putting to some.

Yay! About to dig into this plate of awesomeness!

Yay! About to dig into this plate of awesomeness!

Boooo! I couldn't finish it. It was way too salty. This was what was left after my wife picked at it a little. What a disappointment!

Boooo! I couldn't finish it. It was way too salty. This was what was left after my wife picked at it a little. What a disappointment!

I will try making this again, and fingers crossed- soaking the meat makes it more palatable. I think I will also chef it up a bit with the addition of sautéed onion and some tomato next time. Fancy S*** On a Shingle, if you will!

Have you every had S*** On a Shingle?

Join In

Comments (10)

  • More milk might have helped but soaking or atleast some rinsing should help. I grew up on it. But I remember more gravy so I would suggest more milk reguardless.

      6 months ago
    • Yes, more milk and let it cook down. Also soaking the meat will cut the salt factor immensely. Not any less than 15+ minutes. I recommend ground sausage, it’s the state side version!! They use sausage or ground beef at Annapolis now and I look...

      Read more
        6 months ago
    • Most of the time while growing up ours was done with ground beef and just occasionally the dried beef.

        6 months ago
  • Lol! Good old SOS. I learned that name at about 7 years old. I usually see it made with a ground meat and gravy at our breakfast restaurants.

      6 months ago
  • It looks like a Doctor Who monster... But at least you nearly finished it!

      6 months ago
  • I like the sound of this and I'm going to give it a go, with onions like you say and I think I'll used corned beef instead.

      6 months ago
    • Oh! I never thought of corned beef! Serve it over some home style potatoes for the win!

        6 months ago
  • First problem - you need Frederick's Dried Beef - Fredericks Meats - Quakertown Farmers Market Quakertown PA.

      6 months ago
Loading...
Loading...
10