Review: Reese's Ultimate Peanut Butter Lovers

Are they better than Reese's white creme & peanut butter?

5w ago

FoodTribe almost a month ago I reviewed the Reese's white creme & peanut butter mini cups – and I found them to be absolutely wonderful. Once again I was able to enjoy that sweet Reese's goodness without the chocolate.

As you all know, peanut butter is my chocolate, so I got excited when I saw these. Kyra Sage wrote a post almost two months ago, and I said in the comments, "I will buy all the ones I find. Thank you Reese's!"

Well that is what happened you all. I had ten packs to decide if I like them better.

After eating a couple packs of them at room temperature, I was not impressed: in fact I felt a bit let down. The white creme & peanut butter were still the best.

I put the rest of them in the fridge and figured I would eat them eventually.

A couple days later I saw them sitting in the fridge and decided to give them another chance. After eating the first one, I knew something was different. The peanut butter was a little more flavorful, and a little sweeter as well. After gobbling down the second cup with excitement I realized this is what I was hoping for. To make sure, I went to the fridge and got out another pack. To my delight they were just as good.

FoodTribe I do not understand it but somehow, putting them in the fridge makes them taste so much better than they do at room temperature. Are the Ultimate Peanut Butter Lovers better than the White Creme & Peanut Butter? The only answer I can say for sure is as long as you keep these ones in the fridge, I think they are.

I honestly think I need more of both and to do a lot more testing you all.

Have any of you tried Reese's Ultimate Peanut Butter Lovers? Let me know in the comments. You all are wonderful! I love you FoodTribe!

Join In

Comments (25)

  • I will make sure I stash mine in the fridge..... way back in the back where hubby can’t find them. Of course I’ll share. πŸ˜‡

      1 month ago
  • I would answer this but these are empty and I’ll need to go get more πŸ™„πŸ˜‚

      1 month ago
  • I just tried these! I was a little disappointed too. PB lovers is technically their "Big Cup", wouldn't you think? The PB coating didn't do it for me lol But they're still yummy 😊

      1 month ago
    • Did you try them chilled or room temperature? I think they would work better as a mini.

        1 month ago
  • thanks for letting me know these exist!

      1 month ago
    • No problem! I hadn’t gotten around to trying them yet, so I’m glad this review exists. I’ll definitely pick some up if I see them.

        1 month ago
  • Cold Reese's or Snickers are awesome! These new Snickers blow them out of the water, though! Best mass produced candy I've had in a while!

      1 month ago